The star of any Thanksgiving meal is and has always been the turkey. Crisp, brown skin, and juiciness throughout are the hallmarks of a well-prepared bird. But the turkey is often bland, bone-dry, and, quite frankly, disappointing. Fortunately, these shortcomings can easily be avoided with these simple tips.
1. Get a good bird.
There are many options out there, but if you are willing to spend a little extra, it will be money well spent. I opt for an organic, free-range bird raised on high-quality feed without antibiotics or growth hormones. It tastes better, especially the dark meat, which is my favorite. Happy birds are delicious birds, and the flavor difference between one raised in a free-range environment is far superior to that raised in crowded conditions. You can also get a heritage turkey (an older breed that differs from the standard, broad-breasted varieties that are mass-raised). These birds are rich in flavor and are raised in a pastured environment.
If you can, try getting fresh instead of frozen. It tastes better, and defrosting a turkey can result in some moisture loss.
2. Brine!
I’m a firm believer in brining turkey, whether it’s wet or dry-brined. Wet brining involves soaking the turkey in salt water for a day or two. During that time, the turkey absorbs some of the liquid and tenderizes, resulting in a moist, super-flavorful bird every time. Adding herbs, sugar, and citrus to the brine to amps up the flavor.
Dry brines are a mixture of salt, herbs, and spices you rub on the skin of a turkey. Let the turkey sit in the refrigerator for a couple of days. When roasted, the skin gets deliciously crisp, and you end up with well-seasoned meat. We have a wonderful recipe for a Dry-Brind and Herb-Roasted Turkey that will give you step-by-step instructions on how to make this holiday staple.
3. Cooking tips.
If you’ve wet-brined the turkey, carefully remove it from the brine and rinse it in cool water. Dry the skin well with paper towels and let the bird sit at room temperature for about an hour before roasting. I use a roasting pan with a rack to elevate the turkey and roast evenly around it. Don’t have a rack? Place the turkey on a bed of chunks of carrots, onions, and celery. A preheated 400° oven works well, but feel free to lower the temperature during cooking if the skin gets too dark.
Here’s a suggestion if oven space is an issue: use your outdoor grill! Just make sure it’s heated to a moderate temperature and use that lid to keep in the heat. It works so well as a makeshift oven, and the flavor is even better if you use charcoal!
The roasting time depends on the weight of the turkey, but it should be about 12 minutes per pound. Take the birds’ temperature using a meat thermometer. I use an inexpensive digital instant-read thermometer to get a temperature quickly. I read the temperature on the breast and thighs and make sure that it reaches about 155°F to 160°F to kill off salmonella (the internal temperature will continue to rise a bit during the resting time). Let the bird rest for at least 20 minutes before carving so the juices can redistribute throughout the meat. And try not to go beyond the 160°F internal temperature, or you may have a dry turkey!
4. Carving
My approach to carving is pretty much the exact same as a whole cooked chicken. I start by removing the legs by locating the joint of the thigh bone that sits right next to the side of the turkey. Don’t be timid, push that end of the bone up, away from the body and it should easily reveal itself. Carve the leg between that joint and the body, and voila! You’ve carved the leg. Then separate the leg into two pieces, the drumstick and the thigh, by cutting right where the leg bends. It should cut easily.
I like to carve breast meat by taking a sharp knife and carving each breast away from the breast bone and ribs. Then, I slice the breast into clean slices once it’s completely off the bone. Plate up the carved turkey on a warm platter and enjoy!